Going Down the Rabbit Hole~ In Pursuit of Jewish Austen Fan Fiction, by Mirta Ines Trupp

Going Down the Rabbit Hole~ In Pursuit of Jewish Austen Fan Fiction, by Mirta Ines Trupp

I am forever delving into history books and Internet sites, going down the proverbial rabbit’s hole in search of enchanting stories of elegant ladies and gentlemen of days gone by…who just so happen to be of the Jewish faith.  I surround myself with Austen’s novels, Regency knickknacks, and Judaic memorabilia in the attempt to weave  something Austenesque with a touch of Yiddishkeit. I strive to become, in some small way, a soul sister to our beloved author. Follow me, if you can, as I go through this process of finding commonality and concurrence.

Rabbit Hole Number One:  If Cassandra were to have her head cut off, Jane would insist on sharing her same fate.Have there ever been two siblings more connected? What a remarkable pair. Hmm? Sisters…

Rabbit Hole Number Two What is a soul sister? An Internet search provided the following information: Soul sisters have a strong emotional bond with one another. They have common dreams and aspirations and share fundamental life philosophies— despite having no blood relation. 

Rabbit Hole Number Three: Who could be considered Jane Austen’s soul sister? I looked for a contemporary, someone who might find herself featured in one of my J.A.F.F. stories. Someone who was like Jane in most every way, but one. Can you guess? After countless hours of research, and untold cups of tea, I found her: Rebecca Gratz. Who, you ask? Gentle reader, bear with me and follow along this winding path.

  • Rebecca Gratz was born in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, on March 4, 1781, a middle child among twelve children.
  • Jane Austen was born in Steventon, Hampshire, on December 16, 1775, the seventh of eight children.
  • Gratz believed that with an “unsubdued spirit” she could overcome all of life’s difficulties.
  • Austen believed that by cultivating her talent of realism and humor, she could attempt to earn her livelihood.
  • Gratz, a fervent patriot the whole of her life, was accustomed to the highly political atmosphere of a post-revolutionary America. 
  • Austen, accustomed to having her country at war for most of her life, had three brothers serving in the navy and militia. 
  • Gratz abandoned her early poetry and put her literary talent to work supporting both women’s roles and Judaism in America.
  • Austen began her career as an epistolary novelist. Her work has been a lasting influence on British literature; her stories underscored the realities of women’s’ lives.
  • Well-educated for her day, Gratz attended women’s academies and read her father’s extensive library stocked with literature, histories, and popular science.
  • Austen attend schools for girls. She was, however, allowed to use “some of the same school books as the boys” and had “unfettered access” to her father’s library.
  • Rebecca Gratz fell deeply in love with Samuel Ewing, a non-Jewish lawyer and son of the provost of the University of Pennsylvania. Nothing came of it, however, possibly because intermarriage was one step she could not take. When he died decades later, Gratz visited the room where his body lay, leaving three white roses and her miniature on his heart. Gratz would argue that, from what she saw of marriage, it was a state that brought little happiness. “Better to wander alone through the neglected path of single life,” she wrote, “than with an ungenial companion.”
  • Jane Austen was twenty when she met Tom Lefroy, a young man studying to become a barrister. The Lefroy family intervened and separated the pair. She never saw him again; however, in a letter to her sister, Austen related that she had had tea with one of his relatives, “and wanted desperately to ask about him, but could not bring herself to raise the subject.” In 1814, Austen replied to her niece’s request for advice regarding a possible suitor. “Anything is to be preferred,” she said, “or endured rather than marrying without affection.”
  • Rebecca Gratz was a visionary. She became the founder of the American-style “Hebrew school” and developed the prototype for many women’s charitable organizations. She died on August 27, 1869 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania and was buried at Mikveh Israel Cemetery. Shortly after, her brother, Hyman founded and financed Gratz College, a teachers’ college in Philadelphia in her memory.
  • Jane Austen was a visionary. She is lauded as being the first woman to write great “comic” novels. She used humor to explore the individualism of women’s lives. Austen died on July 18, 1817. Her brother, Henry, saw to her burial at Winchester Cathedral. He arranged for the publication of Persuasion and Northanger Abbey and contributed a note, which for the first time, identified his sister as the author of the novels.

Rabbit Hole Number Four:     I put it to you. Are these two ladies, one Anglican and one Jew, not the very personification of soul sisters?

Jane Austen, The Rice portrait
Rebecca Gratz


Enquiring minds want to know

Sharing is Caring!
Follow by Email
0 0 votes
SUBSCRIBE (optional)
Email alert of:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Colleen Churm
Colleen Churm
April 22, 2021 7:02 PM

Some Souls are born to change the World, slowly, like these two fantastic ladies!

Elaine Jeremiah
November 29, 2020 3:34 PM

Thank you for this marvellous post! It puts me in mind of a book I read recently ‘Reading Jane Austen in America’ which talks about the background and histories of the first readers of Jane Austen in North America. While Rebecca Gratz may not have known anything about Jane Austen, she clearly had a very interesting life, like those that I read about in this book and how reading Austen affected them. And I can see that there are definite parallels between Gratz and Austen’s lives.

Gratz was clearly beautiful too and obviously very clever, like Jane Austen. I do wonder if she ever read any Austen? Because clearly from the book I read, North Americans were reading Austen from pretty early on. 🙂

November 29, 2020 9:50 AM

I have just discovered this website. I am in the process of writing a Jewish Regency Romance where the Jewish characters do not convert. I have been dismayed by the lack of Jewish characters in Regency Romance novels and even more by novels with Jewish characters who convert very easily in order to marry. I have a problem with others that ignore basics about the religious Jews in terms of practice, for example, keeping kosher observing Shabbat. Some times it’s a small issue like describing a Friday night table with one challah. More often characters are portrayed as having no connection whatsoever to Jewish practices. These characters are not presented as being rebellious. They are identified as Jewish but totally non-observant. I was inspired to write my own in reaction. I’m excited to learn about the Meyersons and look forward to reading it.

J. W. Garrett
J. W. Garrett
November 27, 2020 11:30 AM

I suppose you could say all strong women with a vision that does not die are soul sisters. Well done on your ‘rabbit hole’ adventure. I really enjoyed this. Blessings, stay safe, and healthy.

cindie snyder
cindie snyder
November 27, 2020 6:14 AM

It does seem like they have connections. I suppose they could very well be soul sisters!

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x