Chocolate in the Regency, by Zoe Burton

Chocolate in the Regency, by Zoe Burton

I was inspired to write this post this past Tuesday night, when I decided to prepare for watching The Curse of Oak Island on television by making popcorn and hot chocolate. I’m sure others have done posts about it before, here at Austen Authors, but since it’s been a long time since I’ve read one, I didn’t think it would hurt to do one just to refresh my memory. 🙂

As I expected when I did a Google search, lots of sites talk about drinking chocolate in the Regency, and most of them simply copied and pasted information from other sites. I’m going to attempt to put my own spin on the topic and use my own words. It’s been a year since I’ve written a web post (the pandemic shut down ALL my ability to create, sadly), so I can use the practice. LOL

Chocolate mills. Image borrowed from English Historical Fiction Authors site. Click to visit.

I think we all know by now that chocolate as we think of it did not exist in the Regency era. There were no candy bars or boxes of chocolates or bonbons. There was chocolate that could be eaten in the form of small balls or disks covered in sprinkles, chocolate flavored ice cream, ices, and custards, a fudge-like confection called chocolate conserve, and something like what we call truffles and that they apparently called chocolate olives back then. Frankly, if it had olives in the name, I’d not have eaten it at all. Blech. Anyway, the point is, Regency folks did have chocolate options; they just weren’t the same as ours, nor probably as readily available to most people.

Drinking chocolate was the most common way, as near as I can tell, for people to consume my favorite food item. Frankly, at this point in my life, it’s the most common way for me to get a hit of chocolate, as well, though I do still now and again take a shot out of the Hershey’s bottle. 😉 Let’s look at what information I could find about drinking chocolate.

Chocolate cup. Borrowed from English Historical Fiction Authors website. Click to visit.

I remember hearing that all chocolate was bitter back then. I really kind of doubt it all was, because sugar was available, especially in the houses of the gentry, and there were other sugar substitutes that could have been used, as well, like honey. I’m never going to be convinced no one experimented with recipes back then. So, yes, I’m sure some folks drank it bitter, but I’d bet money there were a lot of cooks hammering chunks off the sugar loaf to add to the mistress’ morning chocolate.

Oh, there’s that, too … I can’t see them making just one cup at a time. The way I understand it from what I have read, it took a lot of work to make chocolate. I know I got tired just reading all the steps! If only the lady of the house drank it, I bet they kept what she did not drink in the Regency equivalent of an icebox and reheated it the next day. Of course, that would mean making it frothy again.

Chocolate pot. Image borrowed from English Historical Fiction Authors site. Click to visit.

It seems that to be considered good, drinking chocolate had to be frothy. I can’t look askance at that, knowing as I do my fondness for hot mochas – frothy milk, whipped cream, and all.

Drinking chocolate seems to have required special utensils and dishes, too. Also, they added stuff to the chocolate. Some flavorings, like vanilla or bergamot, and other stuff like eggs and bread, which made my eyes widen and my lip curl just a bit. It seems all that was done to thicken it, but honestly, if you’re drinking it, why can’t it be thin? The Regency Redingote tells me that cooks prepared drinking chocolate differently, depending upon when it would be consumed. If the mistress were to request it in her chambers first thing in the morning, the cook would thicken it so it would hold her until she broke her fast. If it were being served with a meal, it would not be thickened.

But, back to the dishes and utensils … the cook would require a whisk-like utensil called a chocolate mill to mix the chocolate. From what I saw in one recipe, she’d use it two or three times per batch, at different steps of the process. The pot the chocolate was put in and the cup it was drunk out of were also special … they were taller, for one thing. The spout on the chocolate pot was set higher in the pot than a standard coffee or tea pot. This pot also had a lid with a hole. The idea here is that you could stick the chocolate mill into the pot, slide the lid over it, and give it a final stir (even while pouring) to make sure it was mixed well and well-frothed. I’m sure I read that there was a cover for this hole so the mixer could be removed and the heat kept in the pot, but I’ll be darned if I can find that tidbit in any of the articles, now. :/

The cups used for chocolate tended to be taller and hold more that those used for coffee or tea. Which makes sense, since even back then, chocolate had to be better than either of the other two most popular morning drinks. 😉 I wonder if any of our Regency folks thought to mix chocolate in their coffee?  


For your enjoyment …    



Amazon     NOOK     KOBO     Apple

Buy direct from my website    Gumroad

Join my mailing list


Sharing is Caring!
Follow by Email
0 0 votes
SUBSCRIBE (optional)
Email alert of:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Nancy Fifield
Nancy Fifield
May 3, 2021 1:30 PM

I am one of the few whose life turned out better as a result of the pandemic for reasons into which I will not go. However I would much rather we not had it. Thanks for this really interesting and informative article. I knew ladies drank the chocolate just didn’t know what went into so they could.

April 30, 2021 8:24 PM

I would love to try Regency chocolate but am glad that we have many more options now.

Linny B
Linny B
April 27, 2021 12:19 AM

Very interesting post about Regency chocolate. The photos were lovely and informative as well. I think I’ll make myself a bit of hot chocolate this evening. Good luck on your new story! Stay well.

Caryl Kane
Caryl Kane
April 26, 2021 7:48 PM

Thank you for the delicious post!

April 26, 2021 6:00 PM

I, too, lost my ability to write, even to read, during the first months of the pandemic. I lost my humor, which is a hallmark of some of my film reviews.

I am a docent at a local museum and we have been discussing the Mayan method of making chocolate, which was dark and bitter and sugar production, which required slaves. (Europeans craved sugar.) The spread of this beverage, tea, and coffee, which all required boiled water, reduced alcohol consumption, since alcohol and boiling killed organisms, such as viruses, bacteria, and parasites that infected so many humans and killed a score of them. The history of chocolate has such a fascinating story to tell. Thanks for your article, which I found fascinating.

Linda A.
Linda A.
April 26, 2021 1:50 PM

Mmmmmmmm …. chocolate ….

Ciera Garcia
Ciera Garcia
April 26, 2021 11:28 AM

Reading about drinking chocolate in these stories always made me wonder. I just thought they melted regular chocolate like a Hershey’s bar, and just drank. This is so informative! Thanks!

J. W. Garrett
J. W. Garrett
April 26, 2021 11:03 AM

Aaahh, chocolate. Yeah, that’s how you start your morning. Makes me want to yell, HILL! Where’s my chocolate? LOL! Imagine trying to make chocolate for the five Bennet daughters and the mistress. La! Their poor cook. Thanks for sharing. Stay safe and healthy.

cindie snyder
cindie snyder
April 26, 2021 10:16 AM

I am a chocoholic as well! I love it! What an interesting post! I would love to have some with the froth on top yum!Good luck with your new story.

Jennifer Redlarczyk
Jennifer Redlarczyk
April 26, 2021 9:10 AM

Love Chocolate myself sot this article is right up my alley. NOT to mention I have several tall cups that will do nicely, thank you very much. Have a great day and best wishes with your new story.

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x